
We are ready to wrap up our 118th Lite Reads selection, Circus Girl, The Hunter, and Mirror Boy by Neon Yang. This selection was chosen with the end of Asian Heritage Month (Canada) and Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month (USA) (which was May) and the beginning of Pride Month (June) in mind. I apologise for the delays in wrapping it up, I haven’t been doing as well as I’d like and it’s been difficult to keep up. I sincerely thank you for your patience, as I realise this is extremely delayed! There were questions as food for thought on social media as people had the chance to read it and think about it. I will be sharing my own thoughts here. Spoilers ahead for those who have not read the story yet.
Circus Girl, The Hunter, and Mirror Boy by Neon Yang is a 2019 fantasy short story. It is filled with magic, spirituality, and a strong sense of community, especially community as an essential to recovering from traumas. The story stars Lynette, the titular Circus Girl, as she tries to live a regular life. She works in a salon, has a roommate, and everything appears normal until she sees Mirror Boy. Mirror Boy appeared in place of her reflection when she was going through trauma as Circus Girl in her teens, but had slowly faded away. Now Mirror Boy has returned to Lynette’s reflection with the warning that the serial killer appearing in the local news is targeting Mirror Boy’s companions and Lynette is next and last on the Hunter’s list. Lynette goes to Chrissa, a witch friend, for help and it is revealed that Mirror Boy is a wraith who has resisted his urges. Rather than take over humans and make them do awful things, Mirror Boy treats each of his humans as companions and leaves when they ask him, just as he left Lynette when he sensed she no longer wanted him around. Despite Mirror Boy’s benign nature, the Hunter looks to end his existence by killing all of his hosts because of the dark nature of wraiths. Chrissa helps them determine that the Hunter is actually Mirror Boy’s twin brother, aged ten years since Mirror Boy’s death, who has become a fanatic in the aim of ending Mirror Boy’s wraith as he feels responsible for his death. In the end, with the help of Circus Girl and the witch, Mirror Boy takes over his brother’s body for a chance at a normal life.
The ways that Circus Girl, The Hunter, and Mirror Boy show community and lack of community shaping the characters is striking. As Circus Girl, Lynette was alone after she lost her mother, and was preyed upon as a result, having to brutally fight back to keep herself safe. She had some semblance of community in that Mirror Boy was there and the adult women in the circus tried to keep an eye out for her, but she was more alone than not. Seeing her as an adult was so interesting because she had built a community without seeming to be fully aware of it. Lynette is surrounded by people in her life (like her roommate and friends) and even though she feels alone, it is ultimately her community that helps her. She is able to rely on Mirror Boy and Chrissa to help her defeat the Hunter. From the other side of things, the Hunter is alone in the world. He has lost his brother and can’t find an ally even within himself as he believes he is the one to blame (and may well be at fault). It is fascinating to see the ways that Circus Girl survives by her own strength and the strength of her relationships, while the Hunter loses in the end because he has no allies, and rather than lose in death, he loses as he is brought into the fold by becoming a body for Mirror Boy. These types of stories where found family and friendship are so central to queer stories because so many of us had to work hard to find families for ourselves too. It’s probably one of my favourite tropes of queer literature, and I think it works well here (even though the story is not explicitly queer).
I do really enjoy how the setting here feels almost real, but is permeated enough with fantastical elements that you can tell it isn’t our own world, leaving the setting of Circus Girl, The Hunter, and Mirror Boy with an almost uncanny valley effect. This actually suits the story perfectly in my opinion. It left me with the sense of almost-familiarity, but it was never familiar enough to feel safe or comfortable, meaning that as Lynette was being hunted, I felt anxiety alongside her, but I also wasn’t trying to work out what minute details really meant in the context of the world. It’s an excellent dynamic for a short story because it means the author doesn’t waste words explaining background details but the audience doesn’t feel a loss for that. The way it plays with familiar conventions in unfamiliar ways is one of the highlights of this story, even when we shift away from the setting and look directly at the plot. Mirror Boy is an outcast, expected to be evil and to truly possess those he resides in, but not only does he not do that, it is revealed that there isn’t a lot of research to suggest he is a massive anomaly. Everything about this situation feels intensely familiar, but the fantasy twists feel endlessly fresh.
Circus Girl, The Hunter, And Mirror Boy is also a treasure trove of plot twists. Some of them are more expected, such as Mirror Boy and the Hunter being revealed as twins, even as we knew the two had to be connected and that the Hunter looked like and older version of Mirror Boy. Other twists were less expected, at least for me personally, such as the final one where Mirror Boy takes over the Hunter’s body. This didn’t feel out of the blue or anything, and when it was about to happen I realised it was going to, but it was far from something I saw coming a mile away. One of the ways this story makes its twists so interesting, even when I could see what was coming, is through the shifts in narrator. Spending time inside the heads of each of the titular characters made what was happening more of a shock because I was experiencing those twists through through eyes of the characters experiencing them. It had me deeply invested in the outcome as I was learning more about each character and it meant that even when one character knew what was coming next, I didn’t as the reader. I think that interesting or unexpected twists are something that can be integral to a great short story, and I think it really works here. Even still, it did offer up a couple of twists that honestly made me wish the story was longer to see how one part or another would play out.
Overall, Circus Girl, The Hunter, and Mirror Boy by Neon Yang was a fascinating and fun dark fantasy story with twists that I enjoyed exploring. Although I’ve been interested in reading Yang’s work before, this my first experience with the author. I look forward to getting more familiar with their work.
I hope everyone who participated by reading the story and following along on social media has enjoyed themselves. If you have more thoughts to add, you can leave a comment here, or join the conversation on Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, or Instagram. You can also join in on the discussion at Litsy by following @elizabethlk and the #litereads hashtag.
Lite Reads will be taking a brief hiatus. In order to look after myself, I’ll be taking a few weeks away from Lite Reads to do so. That doesn’t mean I won’t still be around (both on the blog and social media), just that I’m stepping back from the weekly project for the time being. We will return on September 12, with a new selection. Please feel free to go through previous Lite Reads selections while we’re on hiatus! There are over a hundred to choose from, across a variety of genres and time periods (recent releases to classics and everything in between). Browse through them, in reverse chronological order, at this link. Thank you so much for your patience; I look forward to starting back up refreshed and clear-headed!
